Monday, 5 October 2015

Theme 4 in retrospect

The fourth theme, on quantative methods, led to some interesting discussions in the seminar, though admittedly not entirely on the supposed advantages of said methods above their qualitative counterparts. On my own part, I have mainy utilized the latter in my bachelor's researches, this decision being largely made from the conviction that for the area of content analysis if by far the most appropriate. This is caused mainly by the fact that such research - into a.o. film, tv series or videogames - featured only a very limited number of research objects, and therefore required a more detailed and less systematic approach. Quantative research, then, would play a large part in the reception analysis part of the same researches, adding a larger scope to put the established into a broader context, as well as shed light on the limitations of it.

Within my group, this was a consensus that was quickly agreed on, with all of us having previously used a combination of both in our academic work. The debate then turned to the subject of which of the two should have the major role in which kind of research, with the again near-immediate consensus being that quantative research worked well primarily in topics that required large-scale respondents and factual data, whereas qualitative researched was more appropriate for smaller scale research where motivations and reasoned arguments were more dominant.

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Hi Julian,
You write a short, concise and highly informative reflection! During my seminar we also discussed the advantages of these two methods in different scopes and research fields and also concluded that a larger scope (i.e. big amount of participants) would fit better with quantitative methods and data than with qualitative. I also agree with you that qualitative research would would be more appropriate for smaller scale research where you want to deepen your understanding of the reasoning and motivations behind data.

Unknown said...

Hi~
Clear comparison between qualitative research and quantitative research is is proposed in your reflection, I really like this. Your group discussion seems more practical because you talked about the role of two kinds of researches played respectively in a paper at the same time. It is available to obtain this knowledge.
Good job!

u1x5o721 said...

I think most of us discussed this in the seminars. Our group came to almost the same conclusion. Interesting paper you decided to read prior to the seminar.

Post a Comment